No Apologies
I don’t owe anyone any apologies for being a mother. I don’t generally ask other parents to apologize for what kind of parents they are, and I shouldn’t feel the need to apologize for the mother I am. I’m sure this is a sentiment most parents feel. So why are we always so sensitive? Why does it always feel like some other parent’s criticizing you just by being around, parenting their child the way they feel their child needs to be parented? Why are we constantly in the comparison business? And why do we constantly get so butt-hurt when the business is over?
I wish I could say I’m over it. I wish this was just something “new” parents did, flailing around in that first year, desperate for some confirmation that they’re doing things right. But I don’t think that’s true. I’m still a relatively new parent. Even though I’m on my second go-round, I’ve still never seen what happens after three, not from a parent’s perspective. That’s three years of experience up against fifteen years of lack. And I still look for that confirmation. And I see other parents doing it too, well beyond year one.
I’ve heard it called the “mommy wars”, which is a misnomer, because fathers do it too. They may do it in different ways, but they do it. I’ve also heard that it’s all made up by the media. I don’t think that’s exactly correct either. It’s definitely perpetuated by the media (Time magazine, anyone?), but I’ve seen plenty of parents take part all by themselves. We sometimes start to choke on the exorbitant amount of information we have culled as a people, and we simply choose sometimes to use the media as a gag reflex. It’s not the media’s fault; we’re just biting off too much too fast. I’ve done it myself.
When my daughter was almost a year old, I re-posted this article on Facebook, after a friend shared it. Two years later, I can say if you’re a parent who’s already made up your mind about breastfeeding, don’t read it. That’s not who I had in mind when I posted it (and probably not who the author had in mind when it was written) and it won’t be useful to you. I don’t exactly vet articles I re-post on Facebook; I simply post them or I don’t. I find that if I have to check them for accuracy, there’s a better article I can post in the process. If they’re opinionated, I don’t mean to imply that I agree with them 100%. If I do, I’ll say so directly. I don’t think it should be assumed. When I posted this one, I didn’t mean to judge parents but to shed light on facts pertaining to nutrition and health. However, in posting it I made the grave mistake of indirectly congratulating myself and expressing pride in myself for breastfeeding my child as long as I had (by thanking my mom for her support). Because it was hard, physically, emotionally, financially, and socially. And because previous to parenthood I was down on myself for the things I hadn’t accomplished. My choices made my first year as a parent extremely difficult, I read an article that reminded me why I’d made one of those choices, and I cried out to the world that I did something right. One thing! Yay, me! Did it come off that way? Was the article even read by my intended audience? No. The road to hell … I just ended up pissing off people who hadn’t breastfed as long as I had or hadn’t breastfed at all, including most notably my two dearest mom friends, who both had to give up breastfeeding, reluctantly, for reasons I now better understand. One had to deal with work; the other had to deal with a medical condition. They were both deeply hurt, and I was hurt for having hurt them.
Ironically, I got a taste of my own medicine later when the same friend who’d posted the infamous breastfeeding article posted another one about alarming C-section rates. Her intention was not to shame women like me who’d had C-sections (she herself had not), but that sure was how it made me feel, as I was still stinging from my reluctant “unnatural” delivery. And she received backlash from me, filled with my own very personal feelings on the issue.
Since then I’ve gained a couple more years of experience, being a parent, dealing with other parents, dealing with people who are not parents, and most dreadfully, reading all kinds of other people’s opinions on parenting on the Internet. The most important thing I’ve learned about that is what’s lost in Internet commentary, along with accountability and tone: civility. In three short years as a parent, I’ve grown so tired of hearing other people’s opinions and trying to get mine across to people with such different perspectives, on such a blinding forum, I almost can’t stand it anymore. And I’ve never had the desire to simply clobber people over the head with the holy notion of what I think. So when this Time magazine controversy arose, I tried to just ignore it. After all, that’s what takes away the power of “the media” to perpetuate anything. And basically, right now I don’t want to talk about attachment parenting anymore than I want to have another C-section. When it all boils down I’m really too busy to stop and ask myself if I’m “mom enough”. The most important thing I’ve learned about motherhood is: the whole time you’re telling yourself you can’t do it, you’re doing it. And if your child is fed, clothed, sheltered, safe, reasonably healthy, and most importantly loved, you’re enough. Anybody who tells you differently is selling something.
So here’s my response: fuck Time magazine. Here’s a cover idea. Why doesn’t everybody just butt out and mind their own business? And as for all the spectators who’ve blown this thing out of proportion: we’re all entitled to our own opinions. We’re not entitled to our own facts. Nor are we entitled to everybody hearing our opinions and treating them as law, despite what those little blinking “comment” cursors tell us in our little self-constructed dens of anonymity, the only place most of us are bold enough to speak up.
Wouldn’t everybody be happier if people just butted out? If it makes us so nervous to see a kid breastfeeding, for example, can’t we just agree to not look? Wouldn’t that help the spectator and the mother relax, not to mention the child? Some say this cover mom should keep her own business out of the limelight, and perhaps she should. But would some mom in California feel the need to pose on the cover of a magazine to prove herself as a parent if her parenting methods didn’t freak out so many insecure assholes? Can’t we just relax and save each other the trouble?
I mean, it’s not like she’s hurting the kid! Anybody who’s breastfed knows it’s not remotely sexual or sexy (a ridiculous notion ironically encouraged by this cover), and anybody who hasn’t breastfed really doesn’t have a dog in the fight. It’s not like the kid’s still on a breastmilk-only diet at three; he’s obviously not starving. And she’s definitely not hurting anybody else. And you haven’t hurt anybody by not breastfeeding your three-year-old. At some point you just have to ask yourself: why does this bother me so much? Then go from there.
Here’s my biggest concern. There are people out there who do much worse to their kids than feed them and give them affection. Kids who are abused, neglected, orphaned, and abandoned need the kind of fire power people are putting into Internet comments about a preschooler breastfeeding “too long”. Imagine how much better off those kids would be if people were driven so passionately to action in their defense. Getting pissed off about something another parent does to care for their child, while remaining complacent about parents who don’t care for their children is not only ridiculous. It’s straight up harmful. And that goes for anybody on either side of the breastfeeding (or whatever) argument.
So maybe everybody should just back off. The media is only as strong as the people who engage, and Time magazine knew people would engage. They counted on it, as usual, and they got what they wanted. I’m not reading the article though. I already have Dr. Sears’s book, and I already know he thinks I’m doing some things wrong, and some things right. About that, he would be correct.
I am a human mother. I am a living example for two human children, for whose lives I am responsible. I know those children better than anybody else, I am the best judge of what is right for them, I get to make the decisions, and I get to ask for advice when I need it. That’s the way it’s always been. Every decision I’ve made about birthing them, feeding them, dressing them, putting them to bed, medicating them, keeping them safe in the car, educating them, and spending time with them has been based on that judgment. And that’s the way it will continue to be. Some of the things I do don’t work out the way I wanted, even when I have the best of intentions, and that’s just life—one more lesson for me and my children to learn. But one thing remains constant. Love is love, and caring is caring. It doesn’t matter which method anybody uses to love and nurture a child. As long as I do what’s right for me and my kids, I am right. As long as you do what’s right for you and yours, you are too. As long as that level of respect is maintained, no apologies are necessary. And if anybody tries to tell you otherwise, you should tell them to fuck off.